By Éric Jouen of La Riposte, member of PCF, Seine-Maritime
Elon Musk regularly claims that Adolf Hitler was “left-wing” or “far-left socialist,” notably relying on the fact that the word “socialist” appears in the name of the Nazi party. This is a deliberately misleading: Nazism was a far-right, racist, ultranationalist movement violently hostile to the left.
In in fact, Musk relayed a thesis already widely spread in France by influencer Brivaël Le Pogam, entrepreneur and creator of highly-followed political content on X: ” Hitler was a far-left socialist “, based on the pretext that the Nazi party was officially called the National Socialist German Workers’ Party (NSDAP).
He also took up the idea that Hitler defined himself as a socialist and drew a political shortcut: if Hitler were a socialist, then “Socialism = Hitlerism.” Very profound reasoning, isn’t it? This argument rests almost entirely on a label. However, obviously, the name of a movement is not enough to define its ideology or actions: one must examine its potential targets, alliances, doctrine, and real policy.
The term “National Socialist” was partly a tool of political and electoral seduction, intended to divert workers who had until then been close to the Social Democrats or Communists. But once in power, the Nazi regime banned left-wing parties, dismantled unions, and imprisoned, tortured, and murdered communists, social democrats, who were often among the first victims of the camps.
The heart of Hitler’s ideology was neither equality nor the emancipation of workers, but racial hierarchy, antisemitism, expansionism, the cult of the nation, and the suppression of parliamentary democracy, all parties except Hitler’s party, and all democratic rights and means of expression. These elements form the foundation of the fascist far right.
Let us simply take a few criteria to judge the difference between socialism or communism and Nazism. Socialism or communism (these two terms actually mean the same thing) aims for greater social and economic equality and the end of exploitation, based on social ownership of the means of production and distribution, whereas Nazism defends the capitalist order by imposing a supposedly “natural” social hierarchy based on racial criteria.
Destroying the organisations that fight exploitation
Hence the fact of fighting and destroying all organisations that fight against various forms of exploitation and oppression: unions, left-wing parties, democrats, etc.
Socialism demands the abolition of ownership of the means of production and fights for democratic economic planning to meet the needs of workers; while Nazism accommodates capitalism, which it strives to protect through racism and the elimination of “enemies from within,” production is supposedly at the service of the Nation, that of a “superior race.”
Internationalism is at the heart of the principles of socialism, expressing international solidarity among workers, while Nazism places “race” above all else; its nationalism thus becomes aggressive towards nations considered weaker.
The parallel with Stalinism is sometimes used to muddy the water. This parallel does exist, indeed. The Stalinist regime eliminated almost all the leaders of the Russian revolution of 1917 and massacred hundreds of thousands of revolutionary workers. Like fascism, it suppressed all forms of democratic expression. It is precisely for this reason that the Stalinist regime, despite its label, has nothing to do with communism. On the contrary, it is its negation.
Stalinism was the consequence of a bureaucratic counter-revolution based on the economy (a nationalised economy) that was established by the 1917 revolution. Hence the alliances and cooperations concluded between Stalin and Mussolini (Friendship Pact, September 1933 and Steel Pact in May 1939) and Stalin and Hitler (German-Soviet Pact, August 1939).
Saying Hitler was left-wing is not a deception to shift the responsibility for the unspeakable horrors of Nazism onto the political opponents of super-rich capitalists like Musk. Certainly, Nazism denounced capitalism in its propaganda, especially before 1933, but its true goal was to subordinate the economy to its racial and warlike objectives.
Reducing this history to the single word “socialist” is like confusing a communication operation with concrete reality. Above all, the Nazi doctrine is based on “racial” inequality, state antisemitism, expansionist nationalism, and the destruction of democracy.
These are the historical markers of the fascist far right. The Hitler regime was a far-right dictatorship that instrumentalised a “social” language to seize power, before destroying workers’ organisations and organising war and genocide.
[From the French Marxist website, La Riposte, original here]
[Feature picture: a Nazi poster equating Bolshevism with Judaism, from Wikimedia Commons, here]
