From Media Lens
[LH editorial note: for 25 years Media Lens has been describing how mainstream newspapers and broadcasters operate as a propaganda system for the elite interests that dominate modern society. It is a campaign worthy of the support of wide layers of the labour movement. As an indication of the quality and value of their output, we are publishing here part of the content an email circular to its regular readers]
………………………………………………………………………….
A recent edition of BBC Newsnight once again highlighted a persistent and pernicious feature of BBC journalism. Presenter Victoria Derbyshire was interviewing Bernie Sanders, the veteran US Democrat politician. He was discussing the US mid-term elections in which the Republicans under Donald Trump had suffered serious losses to the Democrats in Congress:
“The American people want us to address those issues [such as the cost of living and lack of healthcare] and the stupid endless war of Trump in Iran. No more military aid to the extremist government in Israel. That is what the American people want. That’s what we’ve gotta do.”
Derbyshire responded: “Okay, and the Israeli government would deny that they are extremists.”
Sanders immediately replied: “Well, I think most people in America and around the world do believe they’re extremists and what they’ve done to the Palestinians, in my view, is genocidal.”
Over the three years of the genocide, BBC presenters have regularly used the phrase “Israel denies” or “Israel says’” or “Israel would say” whenever an interviewee rightly points out that Israel is responsible for war crimes, genocide and apartheid.
A former BBC employee using the pseudonym Sara told Al Jazeera in 2024, “’Israel has a right to defend itself’. That was the editorial line that was drilled into us, into all of our coverage.”
Sara continued: “People [in BBC News] were terrified of using the word “genocide” in coverage. They still are. You will very rarely see it in any BBC coverage. And if an interviewee says the word “genocide” … the presenter will almost always panic.”
The media watchdog NewsCord has compiled and analysed a detailed collection of BBC video clips titled, ‘BBC: The Would Say Files’.
NewsCord commented via X, “It’s hard to grasp the BBC’s systematic attempt to launder Israeli propaganda until you see the sheer scale of it. Here’s a compilation of them doing it at 2x speed.”
They continued, “As this video shows, BBC presenters repeatedly do this as guests describe Israel’s crimes: ‘Israel would say.’ ‘Israel would deny.’ ‘They would reject that.’”
The watchdog gave an example of a heartless BBC interruption in its compilation of broadcast clips. Bushra Khalidi, Oxfam Policy Lead for Palestine, explained how her family in Gaza had never been allowed to leave Gaza, and how Israel was besieging the Strip and causing mass displacement.
The BBC presenter stated, “I’m sorry this is obviously very personal, difficult situation for you and your family, and as you would understand as well, Israel would say well, they can’t live next door to Hamas.”
As NewsCord observed, “There is no world where that is a rational, humane response.”
They added, “We counted 70 of these denials and justifications in 52 aired interviews. The BBC calls this impartiality. But in not one of those 52 did a presenter raise any of these words from Israel’s own leaders:”
- “ ‘…We are fighting human animals.’ Yoav Gallant, 9 October 2023
- “- ‘It is an entire nation out there that is responsible.’ Isaac Herzog, 12 October 2023
- “- ‘They will not receive a drop of water or a single battery until they leave the world.’ Israel Katz, 13 October 2023
- “- ‘Remember what Amalek did to you.’ Benjamin Netanyahu, 3 November 2023
- ‘- Starving two million people in Gaza until the hostages came back might be “justified and moral’. Bezalel Smotrich, 5 August 2024”
At the time of writing, NewsCord have now analysed 267 interviews broadcast by BBC News between October 2023 and October 2026. In summary, their findings are as follows:
* BBC presenters put Israel’s case, in Israel’s name, to guests criticising Israel’s conduct in Gaza in 252 separate interviews.
* They put the Palestinian case, in its name, to guests defending Israel’s conduct in 15.
* The plainest form, “Israel would say”, was put to critics in 75 interviews. “Palestinians [or any Palestinian group] would say” was put to defenders in just 4.
From its extensive database of BBC broadcasts, NewsCord has uploaded a compilation lasting 48 minutes and 12 seconds of the BBC defending Israel with “Israel would say” (or similar). This compares to just 2 minutes and 38 seconds of the BBC defending Palestinians with “Palestinians [or Palestinian group] would say” (or similar).
This glaring disparity between Israeli and Palestinian perspectives is overwhelming evidence of a strong bias in BBC journalism towards an apartheid regime which has been conducting genocide for over three years.
BBC presenters and journalists are clearly conforming to a script issued from senior management whereby Israeli denials of genocide and apartheid must be interjected whenever an interviewee mentions Israeli crimes. This fake ‘impartiality’ is a cover for promoting Israeli propaganda. BBC presenters intervene far less often when platforming pro-Israel guests by challenging them about the genocidal statements made by Israel’s Gallant, Herzog, Katz, Netanyahu and others.
As Francesca Albanese, UN Special Rapporteur on Palestine, has noted, the BBC, and the wider establishment media, is part of the ‘killing machinery’ that is carrying out the genocide of Palestinians. Needless to say, the establishment media does not want to report this fundamental truth and simply ignored her careful analysis.
The full article from Media Lens can be found here.
Media Lens sends its information and email alerts free of charge, but it can be supported financially here.
The feature photograph is a still from the 49-second video released by the ‘Joint List’ as part of its election campaign, showing drone footage shot over Gaza after its destruction by Israel. The full grim video can be found here.
