The International Court of Justice this week ruled that the policy of the Myanmar government towards its Rohingya minority amounts to a ‘genocide’. This decision is being closely watched in Israel, because a similar case brought before the ICJ is likely to decide that Israel, too, has committed genocide in Gaza.

The Rohingya people are a Muslim minority in northern Myanmar (formerly Burma), a majority Buddhist state. In 2017, they were subjected to an army supposed ‘counter-insurgency’ campaign, which quickly turned into a wholesale assault, a brutal collective punishment meted out to the whole Rohingya people. The Myanmar army killed ten thousand and the evidence put before the ICJ showed that it perpetrated war crimes on a massive scale, including widespread rape, beatings, random killings and even extreme violence against children.

No attempt was made by the Myanmar government to curb its army’s excesses, or punish perpetrators, and the logical conclusion that was drawn was that the one-sided war was government policy. The alleged ‘liberal’ Aung San Suu Kyi, much fated in the west, said and did nothing to prevent it.

It was because of this monstrous military campaign that more than a million Rohingya fled across the border to neighbouring Bangladesh, where they still live in refugee camps around the area known as Cox’s Bazar in the most appalling conditions. More than half a million remain in Myanmar, many of them in camps where they face restrictions on their movement, harassment by the army and frequent blockades in aid supplies.

It is important to note that for the ICJ, the numbers killed, and the proportion it constituted of the Rohingya people, had no relevance to the definition of genocide. Intent was the key issue.

First time a state has been indicted by the ICJ

The ICJ was founded soon after the Second World War, in 1948, in the aftermath of the terrible Holocaust of Jewish people by the Nazis. But it is only the fourth time since then that it has ruled that a genocide has taken place, and it is the first time that it has laid the responsibility squarely on an existing state.

Looking at the evidence in front of it, the ICJ came to the conclusion that the “only reasonable inference” that could be drawn from the widespread atrocities conducted by the Myanmar army, was that the state had the intent to “destroy” a “substantial part” of the Rohingya people.

This case was brought before the ICJ by the Muslim-majority African state of Gambia, and it has been in the process of consideration for years. All eyes will now be on a similar case brought by South Africa to the ICJ, which will deliberate on whether or not the conduct of the Israeli state in Gaza also amounts to ‘genocide’.

In relation to the Rohingya people, the ICJ ruled that the state of Myanmar should compensate all those people impacted by the army atrocities and allow for the Rohingya people to return to Myanmar. Unfortunately, the ICJ has no powers to enforce its rulings, and the oppressive military government of Myanmar will take little notice of the Court.

The massacres and expulsion of the Rohingya people nine years ago shocked the world. But, as horrific as that was, it has been eclipsed by the terrible slaughter and indiscriminate bombing of Gaza. The methods of warfare have been different – most Palestinians in Gaza have been killed by aerial bombardment – but there has been nothing suffered by the Rohingya people that has not also been suffered by Palestinians, and the results are far worse.

Murder of Palestinian children by snipers

In Gaza, the murder of children by snipers is commonplace, as is the kidnapping and murder of doctors and medical workers. In Israeli prisons where thousands of Palestinians are held without trial (including Arab citizens of Israel) there are documented cases of sexual abuse, denial of medical requirements, beatings, deliberate starvation, and murder.

Protests in 2017, within the Rohingya community in the USA against the genocide in Myanmar.

Officially there have been something like 80,000 deaths in Gaza, the overwhelming majority non-combatants, that is not members of any Hamas armed unit. Over 20,000 of those killed were children. Around three times this number have been seriously injured and permanently maimed.

The spokespersons and apologists for the Israeli (misnamed) ‘Defence’ Force lie through their teeth, when they talk about ‘precision’ bombing and a policy to ‘minimise’ civilian casualties. In fact, the IDF have a policy of accepting collateral damage – ie killing innocent people in large numbers – even to target a single Hamas operative. (See our review of NAZA film, here)

The Gaza Strip has been bombed into the Stone Age, with more explosives dropped on it that in any comparable town or city in the Second World War. Every infrastructural element of normal civilian life: homes, water towers, roads, schools, universities, bakeries, shops, hospitals, has been bombed to oblivion. Not because they were ‘military’ targets, or had any importance strategically, but because it is the policy of the Israeli government to make Gaza uninhabitable, and eventually – they would hope – emptied of its Palestinian population.

The scale of the devastation in Gaza can be seen in this 49-second video released by the ‘Joint List’ as part of its election campaign. It shows the grim drone footage shot over Gaza after its destruction by Israel. (The above feature photograph is a still from this).

The remaining two million or so Gazans are huddled into squalid camps, under canvas or other flimsy covers penetrated by the damp and cold winter weather, including, recently, flooding. The Israeli government continues to torment them, by limiting the access of aid to a fraction of what is necessary, and occasionally bombing a tent encampment or a medical facility, always, they allege to target a “Hamas operative”. Months after a supposed ceasefire, Palestinian infants are still being burned alive or frozen to death in the tents where they are forced to live.

Inconceivable to avoid a similar decision on Gaza

Given the decision made by the ICJ in the case of the Rohingya atrocities, it would be inconceivable for the ICJ to avoid a similar decision in relation to Gaza. But in the same manner as the Myanmar government, the Israeli government will ignore the decision, as will its chief backer, the White House.

It has taken nine years to get a ruling on Rohingya and by the time the ICJ makes a ruling on Gaza, the ongoing genocide could be much further advanced. The ethnic cleansing in the West Bank could be accelerated. A second Nakba could be on the cards.

That is why it is essential not to wait for a legal judgement from the ICJ. Labour members and trade unions must demand that the Labour Government act now, by banning all trade with Israel, especially arms, and to take steps to prevent the genocide that is taking place before our eyes.

In November 2024, the International Criminal Court – which is different to the ICJ – issued two decisions about crimes against humanity committed by Israel in Gaza, from at least 8 October 2023 until at least 20 May 2024, as a result of which it issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu and the former Israeli Defence Minister, Yoav Gallant.

These arrest warrants have not been properly tested, because Netanyahu’s international visits since then have been almost all to the USA, not a signatory to the ICC. But warrants were nonetheless greeted with alarm in Jerusalem and met with the ritual accusations of “antisemitism” from Israeli politicians.

The most important outcome of the expected ICJ ruling on Israeli genocide in Gaza, like the ICC warrants, is not the legal mechanisms of implementation, but its huge moral significance. Not that the moral significance means a jot to Israel’s biggest backer, the USA. The Trump administration is openly contemptuous of both the ICC and the ICJ, even imposing sanctions on their judges for their deliberations.

Huge shift in public opinion in last three years

Nonetheless, there has been a shift in public support in the last three years, from support to Israel to support for Palestine, even in the United States. Among the mass of workers and youth, this has taken the form of a huge, tidal-wave of outrage against the war crimes, atrocities and genocide in Gaza – coupled with the ongoing state-sponsored ethnic cleansing of Palestinians from West Bank areas. It has been this historic surge of protest that has begun to shift the political establishment – reluctantly and partially for now – to reconsider its support for Israeli.

The decision of the UK government to sanction companies that engage in the construction of ‘illegal’ settlements in the West Bank is at best a token gesture. Any companies, Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband has said, that help plan, build, supply or market settlement housing will be sanctioned and their UK assets frozen.

Yet the most important element of support for the Israel state – which sanctions and encourages the ethnic-cleansing and the pogroms of Jewish settlers – is the UK military support for the IDF which is untouched. It is doubtful, therefore, that Miliband would depart from the policy of military support for Israel, even in the event of an early ICJ determination that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza.

If there were such an ICJ ruling, it would reinforce the case of all of those who support the struggle of the Palestinian people for their national and social rights. It would be a huge moral victory for Palestine and yet another moral defeat for Israel. But the protests, campaigns and actions against Israeli policies in Gaza and the West Bank should not wait on the ICJ; they must continue with the same determination and energy as before.

Inset picture: members of the US Rohingya community protesting at the atrocities in 2017. From Wikimedia Commons, here

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Instagram
RSS