By Richard Mellor in California

I want to respond to a graphic (which we won’t include here), which is one of many that is doing the rounds in the UK and is getting an echo among some working-class people. I saw it forwarded on social media from right wing nationalist outlets and shared by workers who would not consider themselves right wing or racist. 

I saw similar memes on the Facebook page of a right-wing bigot, Steven Gardner. I think the one I mean here was on an Facebook page of another far-right figure, Ryan Bridge.

The image has three faces and below them the three sentences they got in court for sexual offences: Russell Brand: 10 years 6 months; an Afghan asylum seeker: £400 fine; and an Ethiopian asylum seeker: 12 months. 

Beneath the asylum seekers there is added information. About Brand: “convicted of rape and three sexual assaults against women”. About the Afghan national, “sexually assaulted a 14-year-old girl and a 42-year-old woman” with the note that he was in asylum accommodation. About the Ethiopian asylum seeker: “sexual offences involving a 14-year-old girl and an adult woman” and noting that he is an asylum seeker.

I did a bit of checking myself and every number on it is accurate, and that’s how propaganda works. It doesn’t need to lie. It only needs to leave out the context and let the viewer’s own prejudices do the rest.

So let’s unpack this story a bit. Brand was convicted of rape. Nine of his ten and a half years are for that single count. The remaining 18 months cover three sexual assaults, which puts him in the same range as the Ethiopian, who got 12 months for groping a 14-year-old girl and a woman. The Afghan man, who put his hand on a girl’s butt and slapped another woman’s, pleaded guilty and was fined. Set rape beside groping and you’ll always get a gap. The graphic tries to present that gap as ‘proof’ that the courts favour migrants while native Britons, and white men especially, are the poor victims.

It also leaves out what the migrants face and Brand doesn’t. The Ethiopian man is on the sex offenders’ register for ten years and faces automatic deportation under the UK Borders Act. The Afghan is on the register for five. A British-born man convicted of the same assaults would get the same sentence, or a lighter one, and no one would make a meme about him.

The ‘anti-establishment truth-teller’

Then there’s the choice of Brand for this propaganda piece.  For years he was a hero: the anti-establishment truth-teller, the man the mainstream media were out to get. Now he’s useful as a symbol of a native Briton, a poor Englishman facing the full weight of the law. Those who made him a martyr are happy to use him if it helps them go after refugees.

One point: a £400 fine for assaulting a child is an outrage. But it’s an outrage about how this patriarchal capitalist system treats violence against women and girls, no matter who commits it. Women know this already. They know how few rapes are reported because women and their personal lives are dragged through the courts and very few end in conviction. They are fully aware how often the men who grope, follow and corner them walk away with nothing.

None of that gets memes made about it. The far-right nationalists, and white supremacists discover their ‘concerns’ for women only when the attacker is foreign, has dark skin, is poor and housed in a hotel.

That’s what the graphic is for. A ruling class that can no longer take society forward and that cannot provide even the most basic needs for its citizens and never has protected the rights of women, would much rather you blamed the man in the asylum hotel than ask who built the system that fails women every day. Immigration is a problem, but people don’t risk life and limb trying to reach safety because they don’t like their own home and communities. There is more behind this issue that has to be taken into account.

Behind that graphic is the ruling class that uses racism, religion and at all times misogyny as a means of sowing division within the working class; turns us against one another, weakens our ability to fight back. Class unity is our strongest form of defence. We outnumber them.

In Britain and the US, the ruling class is savaging living standards and social services in order protect the profits of a small minority. The graphic exists to point the finger at refugees or immigrants or any scapegoat rather than the system itself and those that propagate it.

Don’t fall for it. 

[From the US socialist website, Facts for Working People, the original here]

Feature picture of Russell Brand is from Wikimedia Commons, here

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Instagram
RSS